|Back to The CD Reviews Page
LEO & THE PHARMACISTS- Hearts of Oak (Lookout)
I was anxious to take a listen to Hearts of Oak the second Denis slapped it in front of me.
The cover features 4 guys dressed in what look like Irish soccer
jerseys. The fella in the
front (I assume this is Ted Leo) looks like a younger, handsomer version
of Prince Charles, and I’m guessing the 3 Indie Rock-looking schlubs
behind him are the Pharmacists. It’s
slightly disconcerting for some reason, yet I still kind of like it.
I ended up feeling pretty much the same way about the actual CD,
but I have to say that this disc really perplexes the fuck outta me.
I appreciate so much of it, yet I don’t feel all that compelled
to listen to it repeatedly. Hearts
of Oak is the most un-punk sounding Lookout! release I’ve ever
heard, but that’s certainly not a bad thing.
Ted Leo writes catchy, intelligent, and at times complex and odd
pop songs. Occasionally
he’s a dead ringer for vintage Joe Jackson (‘Member him?
He’s underrated as all get out, but that’s another discussion)
on snappy numbers like “The High Party” and “Tell Balgeary, Balgury
Is Dead.” And while I’m
dwelling on old favorites, it sounds like he lifted the main guitar parts
from Billy Bragg’s “The Marriage” and used them on “First To
Finish, Last To Start,” yet I’m not as bothered by that as I normally
would be because it ends up sounding cool.
Other highlights for me here include
“The Anointed One” (hauntingly smooth ditty that eventually builds up
some steam about being disillusioned with an old friend) and the
distorted, bass-driven “The Ballad of the Sin Eater,” which speaks in
a unique voice about being the Hated American.
“Where Have All the Rude Boys Gone?” is a lament about the
disappearance of that great 2 Tone ska sound, and the coda at the end
about Terry, Jerry, Lynvall and Rhoda is absolute joy.
Bottom line here is that there is just no fuckin’ way you can
pigeonhole this disc as one thing or another, and I love that.
But while my head is telling me this is great stuff, my soul is
saying “ehh…” and I’m just not feeling it.
Still, there’s enough interesting stuff here that I’d recommend
you check this out and decide for yourself if ol’ Ted Leo’s really
something special. –Ben Hunter